Mixed Evaluation of “Elden Ring – Shadow of the Erdtree” on Steam

“Elden Ring,” developed by FromSoftware and heralded as a groundbreaking success in the gaming world, recently expanded its universe with the much-anticipated DLC, “Shadow of the Erdtree.” This expansion has stirred up a vibrant discussion among the gaming community, particularly on Steam, where it has received mixed feedbacks.

Splitting the fanbase down the middle is exactly what this expansion did with its mixed feedbacks, something the games at MDCs’ $1 deposit casinos games don’t get. Much of the dialogue centers around the game’s difficulty level, with many players expressing that the challenge may be too steep, even by FromSoftware’s notorious standards. This article delves into the nuances of these feedbacks, examining why the game might be perceived as overly difficult and how this impacts the overall reception of the DLC.

The FromSoftware Formula

To understand the backdrop of the current discourse, it’s essential to revisit FromSoftware’s legacy. The developer is famed for its “Souls” series, including titles like “Dark Souls,” “Bloodborne,” and “Sekiro,” each known for their punishing difficulty. This design philosophy challenges players to learn from their failures, develop strategies, and gradually improve their skills. “Elden Ring” initially continued this tradition, blending high difficulty with an expansive open world, which earned it universal acclaim and several “Game of the Year” awards upon its release.

Introducing “Shadow of the Erdtree”

“Shadow of the Erdtree” expands on the original “Elden Ring” game’s lore, mechanics, and world. It introduces new areas to explore, bosses to defeat, and mysteries to unravel. However, the DLC also scales up the difficulty, particularly in boss fights and enemy encounters, which are more complex and punishing than the main game.

Steam Evaluation

On Steam, “Shadow of the Erdtree” has received a mixed reception, with feedbacks ranging from high praise to significant criticism. The primary point of contention is the escalated difficulty level.

Praise for the DLC

Many veteran players and fans of FromSoftware’s games have praised the DLC for its intricate design, deeper lore, and challenging gameplay. They argue that the difficulty is a core part of the experience, pushing players to explore every nuance of the game’s mechanics and story. These players often find satisfaction in mastering difficult games and view each victory as a significant achievement.

Criticism of the Difficulty

Conversely, a notable segment of the player base feels that the difficulty in “Shadow of the Erdtree” is disproportionately high. Some argue it crosses the line from challenging to frustrating, citing instances where boss fights seem almost insurmountable without perfect execution.

This level of difficulty can be discouraging, especially for players who are not seasoned veterans of FromSoftware’s games.

Balancing Challenge with Accessibility

The debate over the difficulty of “Shadow of the Erdtree” raises broader questions about game design, particularly balancing challenge and accessibility. While FromSoftware’s hardcore fanbase appreciates the steep learning curve, the gaming industry has increasingly recognized the importance of accessibility. This includes providing difficulty options or assists that allow more players to enjoy the game without diluting its core challenges.

Community and Support

In response to the difficulty, the community surrounding “Elden Ring” and its DLC has become a pivotal element of the gaming experience. Online forums, guides, and videos abound, with players sharing strategies and tips. This community aspect can significantly mitigate feelings of frustration, providing a support system that encourages persistence.

The Future of “Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree”

As “Shadow of the Erdtree” continues to be debated among gamers, its long-term reception will likely depend on how new and returning players adapt to its challenges. FromSoftware may also respond to feedback, as in the past, by adjusting certain aspects of the game to create a more balanced experience.

“Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree” is a testament to FromSoftware’s commitment to delivering deeply challenging and rewarding gaming experiences. However, the mixed feedbacks on Steam highlight a crucial dialogue about the nature of difficulty in video games. Whether seen as a barrier or a badge of honor, the challenge level of “Shadow of the Erdtree” undeniably shapes its identity and player experience. As the gaming community continues to evolve, so will the conversations about how games like these are crafted and enjoyed.


Why are There Mixed Evaluation for “Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree” on Steam?

The mixed feedbacks largely stem from the game’s difficulty level. While some players appreciate the challenging nature typical of FromSoftware’s games, others find the difficulty in the DLC excessively punishing, detracting from their enjoyment.

How does the Difficulty of “Shadow of the Erdtree” Compare to the Main Mame?

The difficulty in “Shadow of the Erdtree” is generally perceived to be higher than in the main game of “Elden Ring.” This is especially evident in boss battles and new enemy encounters requiring more precise strategies and execution.

Is “Shadow of the Erdtree” Worth Purchasingif I Found the Original “Elden Ring” Game Too Challenging?

If you struggled significantly with the original game and did not enjoy the high level of challenge, “Shadow of the Erdtree” might be similarly frustrating as it increases the difficulty further. However, for players who are open to seeking help from reddit community resources and guides, it could still be a rewarding experience.

What can I do if I find “Shadow of the Erdtree” Too Difficult?

Engaging with the game’s community can be incredibly helpful. Utilizing forums, guides, and gameplay videos to learn strategies and tips can make difficult sections more manageable. Additionally, taking breaks and approaching challenges with different strategies can also aid in overcoming difficult parts of the game.

Are There Any Plans to Adjust the Difficulty of the DLC Based on Player Feedback?

FromSoftware has adjusted difficulty in past games based on community feedback, but there has been no official confirmation regarding changes to “Shadow of the Erdtree.” Any potential adjustments would likely be announced on the game’s official channels.

How Important is Community Support in Games like “Elden Ring”?

Community support is crucial, especially in games that are known for their difficulty. Sharing experiences, strategies, and encouragement can significantly enhance the gameplay experience and help players overcome challenges they might face alone.

Are there any Accessibility Options in “Shadow of the Erdtree” to Help with the Difficulty?

“Elden Ring” and its DLC generally do not include traditional difficulty settings. However, the game design allows various playstyles and approaches, such as summoning help for brutal battles, which can indirectly adjust the difficulty level.

Can I Play “Shadow of the Erdtree” Without Having Completed the Main “Elden Ring” Game?

It is recommended that players progress significantly in the main game before starting the DLC because the new content is balanced for players who have developed their skills and characters. Starting the DLC too early might result in an even more challenging experience due to underdeveloped abilities and equipment.